Agentic Commerce’s Liability Problem
The pattern
The West has been the better indicator of what trends next in tech and commerce. Social commerce and quick commerce came out of the East, but most of the big shifts started in the West: moving money online, food delivery, booking cabs, online doctor consultations, generative AI, and usage-based billing. The list drifts from consumer to developer products, but from here on I will stick to consumer-facing flows.
What AI infrastructure has delivered so far
Global spending on AI infrastructure has reached $1T in 2026. For the general public, the net result is generative AI, where the browser tab is being replaced by ChatGPT or Claude. The next step, I think, is agentic commerce, and I expect it to be a big industry by 2030.
The signals
Uber's CFO said third-party agents booked 4 rides in the Halloween week, out of roughly 320M trips and orders. Eats saw about 500 agent orders. Tiny, but it is a start.
Shopify reported AI-referred orders up 3.3x, with AI-referred traffic up 2.6x, and shoppers arriving from AI channels converting at a higher rate than from general search. Management said volumes are still small.
Stripe keeps adding agentic capabilities.
Amazon has enabled Alexa to shop on its platform: eligible U.S. customers can text Alexa to search for products, assemble grocery orders, compare options, and complete purchases with approval.
The gap
The signals are there, yet adoption lags. Two things are missing: a security and liability layer, and user confidence.
The networks. Google's AP2 and UCP exist, and the card networks have their own programmes (Visa Intelligent Commerce, Mastercard Agent Pay). But the hard questions are still open. How does a network verify that the agent’s action matches the user's intent? When a dispute arrives, does the merchant take the liability, and if so, why? Is the tracing strong enough to prove who is at fault? Until those have answers, the networks will be cautious about agent-run transactions, and the same uncertainty is holding back stablecoin adoption. That is a topic for another post.
User confidence. What does a user actually gain from an agentic flow? They pay the same price, and they take on the risk of losing money. The honest answer is discoverability. Agentic commerce will reward merchants and products whose listings carry details an agent can read and that are not behind a paywall or login. Long-tail merchants can get there, but the money movement for them is much rougher. Large platforms have the opposite incentive. Amazon has no interest in becoming someone else's API, which is why it blocked Meta's Muse shopping agent in September 2026.
What it likely looks like
It will take time, and there will be several players across the shopping lifecycle. The agent provider finds and compares options, the payment gateway handles the payment, and merchants will outsource dispute handling to third-party vendors, because humans will not sit and analyse traces to contest each case.